Basics, Nutrition

How to Become a Hardcore Fitness Influencer

Or, what I learned reading 18,726 posts on a supplement company’s forum so you don’t have to

Hi everyone, my name is Conor Heffernan and I took Animal Pak as a teenager. For those unaware, a ‘Pak’ is a little packet of pills that promised to cover your vitamins, build muscle, fix your joints and, with a heavy wink, do something about your testosterone. Their marketing in the 2000s seemed to be everywhere and their sponsored athletes were all we talked about sometimes in between sets.

The problem was that in Ireland they were a bloody nightmare to get hold of. Every now and then someone came back from vacation with a suitcase full of them but many of us were left longingly searching for these pills which promised to make us ‘hardcore.’ Each container was full of ‘paks’ which were basically a little plastic baggie of tablets, and I’d carry mine around my workouts like contraband. Some of my mates at the time were taking disco pills and being fun but there I was with my little baggies of filled with B vitamins.

I also spent most of my teens watching hardcore videos on YouTube, on my laptop, right before training. Get your mind out of the gutter, they were ‘hardcore’ training videos of Ronnie Coleman, eight-time Mr. Olympia, squatting 800 pounds and roaring “light weight baby” at nobody in particular.

Later on it was Kai Greene, who trained like a man possessed and then talked about it like he was leading a philosophy seminar, usually on a stairmaster. The background soundtracks were a strange mix of rock and, for reasons I still don’t understand, dance music. Every so often a motivational slogan flashed up on screen. Other times there was something about being a ‘soldier’ or a ‘warrier.’ The idea was that watching these men suffer would carry me through my own sessions, which worked well in theory and not great about four sets in.

Then there was Animal Pak, which made its own videos and made them darker. There was a lot of grey footage, chalk, and spit and sawdust gyms. The man at the centre of the campaigns of it was Frank “Wrath” McGrath, and for teenage me he was absolutely the man. He trained with a hood pulled over his face and the main thing you saw was his forearms.

Weirdly Animal was paying a bodybuilder and then going to a real effort to hide his body. At that time I didn’t find that strange or funny in that, but I do now. In 2011 McGrath turned up in the Animal forum’s “Ask an Animal” subsection, having survived a near-fatal car crash the year before. He stayed there for seven years, through injuries, setbacks and a professional bodybuilding career that never quite went where teenage me expected. The regulars adored him, and I knew exactly why. In 2018 one of them held him up as the genuine article, unlike “some IG famous pretty boy who has never even had to work an eight-hour job.”

A PhD and a good few years later, I went back and reread the whole section, every post from 2007 to 2018. The academic version of what I found is just out in Gender, Work & Organization but this is the other version. Those eleven years amount to a manual for becoming a ‘hardcore’ fitness influencer, and I’ve boiled it down to five simple steps.

Step one… Get picked

You can’t apply to be a ‘hardcore’ role model. Nobody in Ask an Animal put themselves forward as ‘the guy.’ Animal chose its experts for the forum, and an unnamed moderator promoted each one out with a nice speech about who he was and their lifting numbers or bodybuilding accolades. When a new athlete signed, a company rep welcomed him aboard and then reminded him that “with that comes expectations.”

Then there was the Animal kit, which was basically a uniform. One Animal athlete explained that the Animal lifting singlets that he wore were “not sold to the public.” They were only available to sponsored athletes, which made this hardcore garment a staff uniform. Members could look at it, but they couldn’t buy it.

Once you’re in you could lead with your lifting numbers. The powerlifting legend Dan Green opened his thread with his powerlifting totals before he’d answered a single question. Pete Rubish led with his beltless deadlift and John Jewett was a registered dietitian with a master’s in nutrition, but on the Animal forum it came with a world title and a 706lb equipped bench press. Nobody wanted macros from a man who couldn’t bench at least 700.

Step two… Hate the pretty boys

Step two is to final an ‘out-group.’ Every hardcore influencer needs a villain to rally against. In the 2000s it was the tanned lads in the glossy Weider bodybuilding magazines but by the 2010s it was Instagram.

One forum ‘Animal’, Rex, declared IIFYM (if it fits your macros, the diet became meme-ified as the ability to eat Pop-Tarts in the name of science) to be bullshit. His advice was to tell users not to give a fuck what everybody else was saying. Another ‘Animal,’ Machine, had a policy on anything that didn’t work that was, and I quote, “fuck it.” Kirill Malanichev informed the forum that powerlifting “is not a show business” and that you should be known for your records, “not all that fancy mess.”

Incidentally, I bought all of this completely. The magazine models and owners were always selling something. Animal, with its hood and its grey footage, was just telling the truth about hard work. They were ‘authentic’ and not just for the pretty problems. The problem was that Animal was also selling something. They had pills, in packs, and I was the one buying them.

The brand made its money by looking like it couldn’t care less about brands or branding. So if you’re starting, attack the Instagram crowd early and often. Your contempt for marketing will be the best marketing you have.

Step three… Get hurt, then talk about it

Lifts get you noticed but injuries and pain get you trusted.

One ‘Animal,’ P. Diesel, opened his thread with his injury list, which he summed up as “u name it.” Ruptured discs, fractured vertebrae, a torn bicep, a torn pec were all laid out as a sort of laundry list as someone who had ‘done it all.’ Asked about the scar from his abdominal surgery, McGrath told users that “these scars tell my story” and that he wore them with pride. Machine said that his training philosophy came out of his ‘own experiences,’ which was his way of saying he had taken chances, made mistakes, and learned from them.

Now, annoyingly, the academic in me would call this the ‘sport ethic,’ and a belief that playing through pain proves you’re serious. Animal’s experts ran on this belief as every injury was a chance to rally back and make a comeback. The videos I watched as a teenager ran on this idea. Nobody was filming the lad who stopped when his back twinged or ‘felt off.’

So make sure to tell all. Get hurt, tell everyone, come back and tell them that you’re back too.

Step four… Stick around for years and keep answering

This is probably the hard one, and the one Instagram can’t fake or replicate.

Some of these forum threads were downright enormous. ‘Housecalls with The House’ got around 1.1 million views and 3,487 replies. ‘Ox’s Stable’ got around 1.3 million views and over 6,000 replies. In each there were thousands of questions about training, eating, injuries, jobs, family and just about anything else. Every time, the athletes just kept on answering.

Now, annoyingly, I can’t tell you they were working for nothing. They were sponsored athletes and I don’t have their contracts or know if they were actually posting or had someone do it for them. I don’t know if they were being paid by the post, or what Animal required of them either. What I can tell you is how they posted about it. The House signed off every post with “Ask away my Animal brothers.” Rage said that he was there to serve and give back to his ‘brothers.’ Ox said answering questions was his pleasure and that achievements were pointless if you didn’t share them.

They all called it a brotherhood, and among plenty of it was genuinely decent. So it did a lot of good but this was also all done on a website owned by a company that sold supplements. Whatever the contractual arrangements, a busy forum full of grateful young men probably did the company no harm at all.

Users acted as if they knew these men, or at least felt they did. They’d watched them get hurt, recover, struggle with work and occasionally admit that things were going badly. Some of the regulars had been there for years, interacting with them and each other.

A brief pause, because admittedly this stops being funny

I mean some of these steps hurt, and I mean that literally. Being ‘hardcore’ did come with a physical cost.

Dan Green trained through SI joint problems and bulging discs on anti-inflammatories so that he could keep squatting. He spent months training on a bicep tendon that he knew was in bad shape, right up until it ruptured. An ordinary member described knee cartilage damage so bad he’d had to learn to walk again, and the replies mostly told him how to train around it.

Another weighed himself twice a day and got upset when the scale didn’t move. Machine posted a daily schedule that started at 3:55 am and squeezed in two training sessions, a job, writing, study and meditation. Sleep was what he gave up on.

Then there was McGrath. Late on in the forum, he told the other users he’d lost his motivation and was worn down, physically and mentally. Again, I’d spent a good chunk of my teens watching this man to get myself motivated to train, so reading that was honestly grim for me as it showed he was human. It might have been the most honest post in the archive, and the thread responded by looking forward to the comeback.

Some of the Animal athletes did push back against their ‘hardcore’ profile. ‘Nera’ told the forum’s users that “intensity doesn’t cure injuries” and that working through pain only causes more pain in the long run. J-HO warned that going to 100% every week “will catch up to you.” Rubish admitted that most people couldn’t survive certain programmes without getting hurt. These were the forum’s own experts, giving perfectly sensible advice, but it was hardly the stuff that made Animal famous.

I doubt teenage me would have listened either. J-HO’s warning wasn’t the kind of thing that ended up in a motivational video about ‘attacking the weights.’

There was a lot of vulnerability on this forum, which surprised me. Men talking about car crashes, health scares, careers that went nowhere, and being completely exhausted. It wasn’t a cold place or as cynical as I’m letting on. Users did look out for each other, and some of those conversations were very human. But the vulnerability that got celebrated most usually came in a shape the forum already knew how to cheer. Someone got injured and then they made a comeback. If your pain didn’t fit that template, you tended to get training advice instead of a hug.

Eventually the sponsored athletes stopped posting. One long-time member said the section felt “like after a nuke went off,” with only remnants left. He reckoned they’d only ever posted because they were required to. I can’t confirm that, and neither can the forum, but read the last pages and you can see what he meant.

Step five… Cash in $$$

So you’ve spent years proving you’re above all this marketing nonsense. Now is the time to finally sell a training course.

In the same thread where he was the picture of hardcore indifference, Dan Green mentioned cutting his own coaching from six days to four to give “more time to the biz.” He talked about paying health insurance as a small business owner and plugged his seminars and online coaching. John Jewett mentioned working seven days a week and staying up late making content for social media. And Malanichev, the man who told us powerlifting is not show business, pointed users to his Instagram videos and announced a new online training course in the same thread.

To be fair, these men were already sponsored which meant that money was part of the arrangement from the beginning. But by now they had something they could sell by themselves. Years of answering questions, documenting injuries, giving advice and telling everyone how little they cared about the glossy side of fitness made them into people worth paying attention to among the forum’s users.

And, to be clear, I don’t begrudge any of them. They had bills and battered bodies from being legitimate strength and bodybuilding athletes. In many respects it was a case that the internet finally let them earn from what they knew. It’s just that some of what made them valuable to the forum’s users was their insistence that they weren’t like the other lads selling things.

Instagram and YouTube didn’t invent hardcore fitness influencers. These people were already doing it years earlier on supplement and general training forums. They were building audiences, answering questions, getting injured, making comebacks and telling everyone how little they cared about marketing. And then there was teenage me, sitting in Ireland, buying into the whole thing and trying desperately to get my hands on another tub of Animal Pak.

The full article, “Alongside the Algorithm: Masculine Capital and the Forum Economy of Influencer Labor”, is free to read in Gender, Work & Organization.


Discover more from Physical Culture Study

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Tell Me What You Think!